Not All Fats are Created Equal:
Key Insights for Heart Disease
by Connie Guttersen, RD PhD,
author of the Sonoma Diet
The important association between the Mediterranean-style
diet and lower rates of heart disease has been shown in landmark
studies, such as Ancel Key's Seven Countries Studies
and the Lyon Heart Studies. The Mediterranean diet
is based on olive oil, nuts,
seafood, fruits, vegetables, grains, and legumes. The
health message derived from these studies is that the type
of dietary fat is more important than total fat.Despite the
abundant research to support this concept, many Americans
have been trying to cut the fat from their diet by eating
more fat-free products. Such a diet has not been shown to
be the best heart healthy approach. While these diets will
reduce cholesterol, its at the expense of a decreased
level of high-density lipoproteins and an increased level
of triglycerides. On the other hand, a diet that contains
a moderate amount of fat, primarily monounsaturated, will
decrease an elevated blood cholesterol and low-density lipoproteins.
It will also maintain the level of high-density lipoproteins
and lower the elevated triglyceride levels.
 |
 |
|
(click on diagrams for larger view)
|
Current diet controversies are largely related to whether
monounsaturated or carbohydrates should be substituted for
saturated fat, and what quantity of monounsaturated fats should
be consumed. A recent study conducted by Harvard School of
Public Health used a regression analysis of data from the
Nurses Health Study (80,082 women for 14 years) to
show that the intake of monounsaturated fat was protective
against coronary heart disease. More recent information compares
different sources of monounsaturated fats (olive oil, peanut
oil, peanuts and peanut butter) to the American Heart Association:
Step II cholesterol lowering diet (low fat, high carbohydrate).
In this study, Etherton, et al. proposes that diets moderate
in dietary fat, (35% of total calories), and primarily comprised
of monounsaturated fat will lower total and low-density lipoprotein
cholesterol to a degree similar to that of the Step II diet.
Moreover, the monounsaturated studies had the added benefit
of not decreasing high-density lipoprotein or increasing triglycerides,
as the Step II diet did. In this particular study, all the
different monounsaturated sources contained approximately
77% oleic acid. However, differences were seen in their individual
ability to decrease cardiovascular risk. These differences
in cardiovascular risk reduction may be attributed to additional
components such as antioxidants and phytochemicals, which
were present prior to refinement.
Cardiovascular disease is also affected by free radical damage
in the artery walls as well as in the low-density lipoproteins.
Clearly, any process that would increase the presence or activity
of antioxidants in these areas would minimize the oxidative
damage. Recent investigations have focused studies on oxidized
low-density lipoproteins. Oxidized low-density lipoproteins
are more atherogenic and are responsible for early formations
of atherosclerotic plaque. One of the contributing factors
to the formation of oxidized low-density lipoproteins is related
to the type and amount of dietary fat consumed--specifically,
the degree of unsaturation of the fat. We know that saturated
has no double bonds, monounsaturated has one and polyunsaturated
has more than one. Degree of unsaturation or number of double
bonds is a marker for oil stability and susceptibility for
oxidation. Free radical damage tends to occur where there
are double bonds, therefore, the more double bonds, the greater
the susceptibility for oxidation. Unfortunately, one of the
more stable fats, saturated, is also the most atherogenic.
However, monounsaturated only have one double bond, thus they
are stable and do not have atherogenic properties. Studies
have shown that enriching a diet with monounsaturated fats
at the expense of polyunsaturated fats leads to low-density
lipoproteins that were less susceptible to oxidation. Other
data suggest that monounsaturates may also decrease platelet
aggregation and reduce blood pressure. All of this data collectively
suggest that diets that contain a moderate amount of fat,
but primarily comprised of monounsaturated fat, have multiple
benefits for cardiovascular risk.
(click on diagram for larger view)
In
conclusion, it is necessary to remember what we already know.
Limiting the amount of saturated fat and hydrogenated fat
in the diet is a good idea. In addition, recent advances in
the scientific literature recommend replacing some of the
polyunsaturated fats with monounsaturated fats. This
chart provides a summary for the foods, which are
high in monounsaturated fat and low in saturated fat.
You can find a number of recipes for foodservice
and consumers
that include olive oil, olives and other foods high in monounsaturated
fat throughout this site.
Top
|